Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity

Chat Leftovers: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards


Would a wood board carry less risk of contamination or knife damage? (Julia Ewan -- The Washington Post)

Got questions for the Food staff? Your weekly chance to ask them comes up in just a few hours. Join us at 1 today for our Free Range chat. On this week's guest list: Deborah Madison, one of the country's best-known vegetarian cookbook authors. And, as always, there'll be prizes for a couple of lucky chatters.

We'll get to as many questions as we can in the course of the hour, but there are always leftovers. Here's one from last's week's chat.

Would you please point me to some reliable, science-based information on the relative merits of wood vs. acrylic cutting boards? I am interested in both their food safety features and their effect on knife blades. I have heard conflicting information on whether wood boards are actually a food safety peril or a food safety benefit; likewise, I have heard that some acrylic boards can dull knife edges. I’d like to read something factual and informative that will help me evaluate my choices.

You're right about conflicting information. There's a lot of disagreement about which kind of board is safer. But I thought this report from the Hospitality Institute of Technology and Management looked reasonable.

The researchers contaminated cutting boards made of wood and plastic, measured the bacteria that were present, then cleaned the boards with different solutions. The results indicate some differences, but the differences aren't as dramatic as you might expect. It turns out that a rinse with water is more effective on wood than on plastic. The most effective cleaning product -- a mix of water and vinegar at a ratio of 4 to 1 -- removed nearly all bacteria from the plastic and wasn't as effective on wood.

That result, by the way, conflicts with a 1993 study at the University of Wisconsin that got a lot of publicity back in the day. It showed wood to be markedly easier to disinfect. But its methodology was later questioned. This HITM study is somewhat more recent.

As to which is easier on your knife, the consensus seems to be that a board made of end-grain wood (cut crosswise, against the grain) will be slower to dull the blade. These are usually boards made by glueing several pieces of wood together. Side-grain boards are a little harder, so they dull the knife more, and because they are usually made of one large piece of wood, they tend to warp when you get them wet.

-- Jane Touzalin

By Jane Touzalin  |  July 29, 2009; 7:00 AM ET
 | Tags: Free Range, Jane Touzalin, cutting boards  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   Del.icio.us   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Local Appetite Key to Fixing School Lunch
Next: Eight Ways to Healthful Dishes

Comments

I bough a wood cutting board, and I hate it! It's very flaky, so I often had little wood fibers in my food. Did I just buy a bad wood cutting board? I've been sticking with my plastic ones.

Posted by: shauch | July 29, 2009 11:47 AM | Report abuse

I just toss the food up in the air, chop it with my knife, and catch the pieces before they hit the floor. It's the only way to be safe from the microbes. Oh wait...airborne microbes. CURSES!

Posted by: Handsome_John_Pruitt | July 29, 2009 12:41 PM | Report abuse

I have a couple of bamboo cutting boards. No flakes or chips or anything from the board. I love it.

Posted by: lalalu1 | July 29, 2009 1:42 PM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
 
RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company