And Another Thing (About Sabathia)
I've had a nice mix of responses to the column on CC Sabathia this morning. However, almost all the negative e-mails, from sharp people and good fans, make the same point: "But EVERYBODY use to start on three days' rest. Why can't CC do it for two weeks?"
I grew up as a kid with a Warren Spahn baseball card in my wallet so I know about stamina, complete games and pitchers past age 40 throwing far more innings than anybody today. And in Spahn's case, pitching a 15-K, two-hit shutout against the Yanks in the World Series after one of those season which would seem impossible today.
However, the well-meaning "they used to do it" crowd is making the easy obvious point. But I believe they are missing the pertinent point. Athletes train their bodies for specific tasks. When they change their work patterns, regardless of era, they risk injury. What if the Orioles had asked Jim Palmer, after a max-inning season, to pitch on TWO days' rest, instead of thee days', for FOUR straight pennant race or post-season games?
Wouldn't that have been irresponsible, excessive? Of course it would. And they didn't do it. It's the same thing. Palmer trained his whole career for pitching on the fourth day. For whatever combination of reasons, it suited him. Like others in that era, he may have pitched on two days rest a couple of times -- as Mickey Lolich did in Game 7 of the '68 Series. But nobody -- not even Spahn and Sain and pray for rain -- ever pitched on what was considered "short rest" (just two days) in their era FOUR straight times.
Baseball identifies the players who thrive under the playing conditions of THAT era. Sabathia has flourished under five-man rotation conditions. Who knows exacly why? If CC had a $100-million contract with the Brewers and they asked him to do what he's now doing, that's fine. Risky, but legit to ask him. But they rent this guy for thee months and now they are asking him if he will to do something ("Oh, sure, I'll be glad to do it") that, as far as I know, nobody has ever done in a pennant race and post-season: pitch on short rest -- as it is defined in that era -- four straight times.
By the way, overworked pitchers seldom grab their arm in pain in October. They finish the season just fine. They find out the damage that they've done NEXT season.
So, it's in '09 that I'll really be rooting for CC.
Posted by: ce | October 2, 2008 2:32 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: CALSGR8 | October 2, 2008 4:23 PM | Report abuse
The comments to this entry are closed.