Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
On Twitter: PostSports  |  Facebook  |  E-mail alerts: Redskins and Sports  |  RSS

Derek Jeter: A Latter Day Robin Yount?

Of all the interesting events during the World Baseball Classic, one may have a longer, more resonant effect on baseball's landscape than any other. Here's a hint: It didn't happen in the championship game, and it didn't even have anything to do the Netherlands' monumental upset of the Dominican Republic.

No, the moment that may stand out for Major League Baseball was the error that sealed Japan's win over the U.S. on Sunday night. It was Derek Jeter's fault; he botched a relatively routine throw from a difficult grounder, and it cost the U.S. In the long run, it may also eventually cost him his position with the Yankees, too.

The theory goes a little like this: It's becoming more commonly accepted that Jeter is, without a doubt, one of the major leagues' worst defensive shortstops. The data behind the fact is nearly unassailable -- he's always struggled to throw across his body when ranging to his left, and he now is more error prone making the athletic jump throws and relays that were once his hallmark. One University of Pennsylvania Wharton School study found that Jeter was the worst defensive shortstop in the major leagues in 2008. Sure, Jeter still has a penchant for a highlight play that saves runs, but he's equally prone to the egregious error, which is precisely what we saw on Sunday night.

Now, as others realize Jeter is more of a defensive liability than a strength, pressure is slowly starting to build for the Yankees to shore up their shortstop defense. The team also has two shortstop prospects progressing rapidly through the minor league ranks, and everyone knows the Yankees are never afraid to make a splash on the free agent market, or via a trade. And the Marlins, new stadium or not, will be due for another salary purge within a year or two. The Red Sox already inquired about Hanley Ramirez this offseason, and putting him in pinstripes would push Theo Epstein and the Boston brass completely over the edge.

Put the factors together, and you could make a case that Jeter's tenure as the starting shortstop of the Yankees could come to an end, perhaps as soon as the end of his current contract, which runs out after the 2010 season.

Naturally, that won't be the end of Jeter as a Yankee. He's the face of the Yankees, and he will always be as long as he still puts on a uniform. The odds of Jeter ever suiting up for another team seem about as astronomical as Scott Boras telling Stephen Strasburg to sign for the major league minimum. Jeter and the Yankees are a mutually beneficial partnership, for the stability of both the team and Jeter's wallet.

Luckily, there's still a role in which Jeter could be hugely beneficial to the team: As New York's next center fielder.

The Yankees have never truly been able to fill the center field void left by another 90s Yankee icon, Bernie Williams, and this year the position will be manned by two outfielders as nondescript as you can get: Melky Cabrera and Brett Gardner.

That just means that the position is truly up for grabs, and unless Gardner becomes the next Carlos Quentin, it'll be ripe for the taking come 2011 when Jeter could step in and switch positions.

The transition is anything but unprecedented. Robin Yount made the switch with more success than anyone else, and Jeter has already been compared to the Hall of Famer for his earlier career as a heavy hitting shortstop.

It's a move that makes sense, even if Jeter doesn't want to hear it. And, according to this article by the New York Daily News' Mark Feinsand, he's not even considering the switch.

"That's the plan," Jeter said. "I haven't really thought about how long I'm playing. I take it one year at a time; I don't sit down and say, 'Well, I hope I'm playing in two-thousand whatever.' It's a tough question, because I haven't really thought about it much."

Could Jeter, who has been named to eight American League All-Star teams in his 12 big-league seasons - four as the league's starting shortstop - ever see himself playing another position?

"Right now?" Jeter said, "No. ... Hopefully, I don't have to think about that for quite some time."

Somehow, that doesn't seem likely.

By Cameron Smith  |  March 25, 2009; 12:03 PM ET
Categories:  Yankees  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Orioles Getting the Band Back Together
Next: Moment of Levity: The Big Picture


As a Red Sox fan, I hope to see Jeter at SS for years to come.

Posted by: pondaz | March 25, 2009 12:12 PM | Report abuse

Ditto that, pondaz. The Yankees would be a terrifying force if they ever made an effort to field the best possible team instead of the most glorious.

Posted by: petey5 | March 25, 2009 1:26 PM | Report abuse

Should anyone presume that Jeter can play a capable CF right now much less a year or two down the road? The obvious position for the guy is 3B. Moving A-Rod someplace. It is going to be interesting.

Posted by: dfh123 | March 25, 2009 2:01 PM | Report abuse

At this point, A-Rod may have too much bulk to move back to SS, but maybe Cody Ransom or someone else can become the SS of the future. I do hope he stays at SS for a long time, though, for the same reason as Pondaz.

Posted by: jca-CrystalCity | March 25, 2009 2:49 PM | Report abuse

Forget Robin Yount, Jeter is more like a modern day Alan Trammell or Barry Larkin: a glorified $20M/year singles hitter. Aside from the pitiful fielding skills, don't forget that his offense has dipped the last two seasons. The Yankees should have moved him to 3rd or as an OFer when they signed A-Rod. An interesting fact is that since the Yankees have named Jeter their Captain, they've won zero World Series. He's a good serviceable player and an All-Star early on in his career, but he's not a slam dunk first ballot HOFer that media has everyone believing he is.

Posted by: 1buj | March 25, 2009 3:11 PM | Report abuse

If he doesn't have the range or skill to play short, how can you justify moving him to CF? Aside from shortstop, CF is the hardest position on the diamond. It requires range, arm strength, and accuracy. Not much different than SS. For the reasons you listed that he needs to leave short, wouldn't be more well-suited in LF, RF, or better yet, First base?

For the record - JROLL makes that play in his sleep and the game ends differently. Platooning at SS was a bad move from the get go, especially with having a game changer like Rollins on the bench. There are many other reasons the USA didn't reach the final, but that one is obvious.

Posted by: PhilliesPhan | March 25, 2009 3:55 PM | Report abuse

I don't care for him much either, obviously, but he'll get into the Hall on the first ballot. He's going to end up with 3,000+ hits having played at a premium position for most of his career (even if he's played it poorly the last few), he won four World Series, and he played on a ton of All-Star teams.

But that's for later. Right now, he's just a lead-footed shortstop dragging down my favorite team's main rival, and I love it.

Posted by: pondaz | March 25, 2009 5:04 PM | Report abuse

The best time to move Jeter to CF was when A-Rod joined the team 5 years ago. Now, Jeter's a step or two slower and would be better suited to 3B or a corner OF position. The problem is, his power hasn't increased with age, so he wouldn't be an above-average hitter at those positions the way he's been at SS, and probably not an above-average fielder either. So moving Jeter is problematic, though keeping him at SS is probably worse.

Posted by: DrewDC | March 26, 2009 7:45 AM | Report abuse

Wow, great set of commets up there. Nice.

Posted by: dfh123 | March 26, 2009 8:15 AM | Report abuse

Or how about if Robinson Cano's dropoff continues they move Jeter to 2b?

I think the Jeter/A-Rod switch would work out better than having Jeter at SS.

PhilliesPhan - where are you going to put Teixeira if you move Jeter to 1B?

A corner outfield spot (probably LF) would hide him better than CF, but I would think 2B would be the best bet, perhaps moving Cano to SS or using him as trade bait.

Posted by: adampschroeder | March 26, 2009 11:23 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company