Behind McCain's S.C. Win
Arizona Sen. John McCain won the South Carolina GOP primary, losing only the party's most conservative voters and doing significantly better among evangelicals than he did in Iowa.
McCain's victory gives his campaign a boost headed into the Florida primary on Jan. 29, and is a sweet turn for the senator whose presidential bid eight years ago fizzled in the Palmetto state.
In 2000, McCain's bid faltered when he lost Republicans by more than 2 to 1 to George W. Bush. This year, he ran evenly with runner-up former Arkansas governor Mike Huckabee among party regulars, and won by a large margin among independents, as he did in New Hampshire. Eight in 10 South Carolina voters were Republicans, making his improvement in this core group particularly important.
Six in 10 GOP primary voters were evangelical Christians (same as in Iowa), but while only 10 percent of evangelicals in Iowa supported McCain, 27 percent voted for him in South Carolina. (He also got 28 percent among evangelicals in New Hampshire, where former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney was his main rival.)
McCain also won by better than 2 to 1 among moderates and liberals, and split "somewhat conservative" voters (32 percent for McCain, 30 percent for Huckabee). About a third of voters described themselves as "very conservative," and they broke for Huckabee by better than 2 to 1, not quite enough to overcome McCain's advantage in the less conservative groups.
One factor working in McCain's favor was that 43 percent of voters said he is the most electable Republican candidate. Far fewer, 23 percent, said Huckabee has the best shot at beating the Democratic nominee; 19 percent said so about Romney.
Just 6 percent called electability the single most important candidate quality, but 42 percent of these voters opted for McCain, only 15 percent for Huckabee. More than four in 10 said the top attribute was "shares my values," about a quarter said candor and a quarter experience. Huckabee dominated among "values voters," McCain among those seeking a solid resume.
A quarter of the electorate had served in the military, and they broke for McCain by a narrow seven percentage points. In 2000, 48 percent of veterans voted for McCain, 47 percent for Bush.
The economy was the top issue, according to the network exit poll conducted at 35 randomly-selected precincts. Next on the list was immigration, followed by Iraq and terrorism. Economy voters divided evenly between McCain and Huckabee.
The table below compares the vastly different GOP electorates in South Carolina and New Hampshire, both won by Sen. McCain. Please see previous election day Trail posts on the South Carolina contest and the Nevada caucuses (Democrats, Republicans).
| Two States, Two GOP Wings, Same Winner | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New Hampshire | South Carolina | |||
| 2008 vote for McCain | 37 | 33 | ||
| Republican | 61 | 80 | ||
| Independent | 37 | 18 | ||
| Evangelical Christian | 23 | 60 | ||
| Very conservative | 21 | 34 | ||
| Moderate/liberal | 45 | 31 | ||
| Abortion legal in all/most cases | 52 | 28 | ||
| Abortion illegal in all/most cases | 44 | 70 | ||
| Positive towards Bush administration | 50 | 69 | ||
| Negative towards Bush administration | 49 | 30 | ||
By Jennifer Agiesta |
January 19, 2008; 10:44 PM ET
Previous: Hitting the Mark on Issues |
Next: Demos for next Democratic primaries
Posted by: Nym, by the sea | January 20, 2008 10:45 AM
another factor behind McCain's win was Thompson shaving off votes that otherwise would likely have gone to Huckabee.
too much is being made of McCains 3-point margin of victory.
Posted by: martin | January 20, 2008 11:59 AM
The comments to this entry are closed.
"One factor working in McCain's favor was that 43 percent of voters said he is the most electable Republican candidate."
Yes, and this is critical to the party and the country. It's really important to bipartisanship that the election be more of a horse race than Karl Rove would have had it been.
The country is sick of easily 10 years of rabid extreme partisan attack behavior, and the sooner the GOP figures that out, the better off the party will be.