Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Posted at 12:25 PM ET, 10/28/2010

Why Linus and, to a lesser extent, Lucy are the only members of the Peanuts gang to be trusted in 'It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown'

By Jen Chaney

Forget Charlie Brown. Linus Van Pelt is the member of the Peanuts gang who puts up with the most unnecessary abuse.

Just watch "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown" -- which, as it happens, airs tonight at 8 p.m. on ABC -- and make a list of how many times the kid gets screamed at or called a blockhead or threatened with legal action simply because he chooses to spend his Halloween night in a pumpkin patch. Back in 1966, when this special first aired, they called that delusional. Now we'd probably laud Linus for being eco-conscious, getting back to nature and showing his support for the local food movement.

Honestly, the only two Charles M. Schulz-created characters who can be trusted on any level in this half-hour animated classic are the Van Pelt children. Everyone else's behavior is borderline reprehensible.

Take Sally. When Linus invites her to hang out in the pumpkin patch, she's initially thrilled. An evening with her Sweet Babboo? What could be better?

Then she gets a better offer. Tricks-or-treats and a crankin' party at Violet's house. All of a sudden hanging out in the chilly night air while being mocked by her older brother's posse of meanies doesn't sound so good. And when the Great Pumpkin doesn't even bother to show, she turns on Linus. "I'll sue!" she shouts. "I want restitution!"

Really, should we have expected more from the innocent young girl who, in "A Charlie Brown Christmas," asks Santa Claus to send her cash in the forms of tens and twenties? Sadly, probably not.

Meanwhile, Snoopy has the gall to cackle that deranged Bill Melendez-as-a-beagle laugh of his when he reads Linus's "Dear Great Pumpkin" letter, which is pretty rich coming from a dog who thinks he's a World War I flying ace, and even in his delusional fantasies still manages to get his plane shot down by the Red Baron.

Then there's Charlie Brown, who disappoints most of all. When Linus opens up to his friend and explains how the Great Pumpkin is going to rise up out of the pumpkin patch, he says, "You must be crazy. When are you going to stop believing in something that isn't true?"

Gee, I don't know, Zig Zag Boy. Maybe when you stop believing that Lucy really will let you kick that football, a gag that literally two minutes ago in TV-special time you fell for again even though that signed document she presented clearly wasn't notarized?

How short is Charlie Brown's memory? Does he not recall that during "A Charlie Brown Christmas" it was Linus's faith in him that made a tree grow and also allowed the entire Peanuts gang to decorate it by doing nothing more than making swift motions with their hands?

Charlie Brown Christmas Parody MAD TV

| Myspace Video

Maybe this is why Charlie Brown gets so many rocks in his trick-or-treat bag on Halloween night. It's payback ... although someone in that homeowners' association clearly needs to investigate why so many parents are handing out rocks on Halloween.

And then there's Lucy: blunt, borderline violent Lucy.

Lucy can be nasty. There is nothing commendable, for example, about the way she tells Charlie Brown that his invitation to Violet's Halloween party was clearly a mistake. (You just remember that 20 years from now, Van Pelt, when good 'ol Violet puts you on the B-list for her wedding.)

But you always know where you stand with her. And as a sister, she has Linus's back.

Sure, she calls him a blockhead and threatens to slug him. But in fairness, as a member of the Van Pelt family, she's the only one with a genuine right to feel like her reputation has been besmirched by his Great Pumpkin obsession. And give her some credit for making sure to ask for extra candy for Linus, even when he refuses to go trick-or-treating.

Let's not forget that Lucy is a psychiatrist. If she weren't an elementary school-aged psychiatrist -- and if every adult in her sphere knew how to use words other than "Wah wah wah" -- she could theoretically take action to have Linus committed. But she doesn't. Instead, she dutifully sets her alarm clock for 4 a.m., gets up, drags baby brother out of the pumpkin patch and tucks him in to his warm, cozy bed. That's love, people.

And isn't that what Linus Van Pelt deserves? Is he any more deluded than, say, the Chicago Cubs fan who firmly believes his team is finally going to pull it out this year? Or the political science major who insists that the democratic process doesn't have to devolve into partisan name-calling? Or the "Pretty in Pink" obsessive who is sure that somehow, during the 107th viewing of the movie, Andie will finally choose Duckie?

In the end, isn't Linus Van Pelt just another sweet, determined and unwavering voice for hope and sincerity in an animated world gone mad?

By Jen Chaney  | October 28, 2010; 12:25 PM ET
Categories:  Pop Culture, TV  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Marie Claire's Maura Kelly: Should she be fired for "fatty" comments?
Next: 'The Office's' John Krasinski, also a time traveler?


Love, love, love this.

On a related note - one year, maybe around 86 or 87, there was a really creepy (to a 7- or 8-year-old) Garfield Halloween special. I just remember a pirate ship and a haunted house. I only remember seeing it that one year, and it was great!

Posted by: Aloe9678 | October 28, 2010 12:48 PM | Report abuse

How can a pumpkin patch be sincere?

/can't wait 'til my kids are old enough to understand this show

Posted by: cao091402 | October 28, 2010 2:15 PM | Report abuse

I'm with the previous commenters: this is wonderful and I can't wait until I have children so they can be old enough to watch.

I just sent my husband an email telling him that despite the other errands we need to run tonight, we NEED to be home by 8pm. I think there's 1 Pumpkin Ale left in the fridge...

Posted by: capecodner424 | October 28, 2010 2:41 PM | Report abuse

In the original Peanuts cartoons, Linus used to quote scripture. Then his belief switched to the non-sectarian Great Pumpkin. "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown" was Schultz's allegory on faith in the modern world.

Posted by: jimward21 | October 28, 2010 4:01 PM | Report abuse


This is on opposite Shrek Halloween. Why Disney are you letting Shrek be on a competing network? Why?

Oh well, I have it on disc.

Posted by: epjd | October 28, 2010 4:08 PM | Report abuse

Why Disney are you letting Shrek be on a competing network? Why?

Oh well, I have it on disc.

Posted by: epjd | October 28, 2010 4:08 PM

Disney doesn't have much of a choice in this. Shrek is not their property to my knowledge.

Posted by: jes11 | October 28, 2010 7:46 PM | Report abuse

OMG Aloe! I thought I was the only one who remembers that terrifying Garfield special! No one else seems to have heard of it, but it makes me shudder just to think about it...

Posted by: snuggie | October 29, 2010 9:15 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company