Why second-degree murder in Va. case?
After reading Tom Jackman's story about how David A. Patton was charged with second-degree murder after allegedly breaking into Stephen A. Carr's house, binding Carr and his girlfriend and, when Carr struggled, fatally shooting him, several readers asked why Patton had only been charged with second-degree murder.
Here's Tom's response:
On the issue of second-degree murder: Fairfax prosecutors and magistrates routinely issue this charge when it is being done quickly. They can upgrade it to first-degree murder at the grand jury stage, when they know more.
This shooting happened late on a Sunday night, and by the time the police were ready to get a warrant it was probably past midnight. At that point, they may not have had all the background to file murder one, so why bother.
The longtime prosecutor, Robert Horan, always said that a murder charge in Virginia is automatically considered second-degree unless otherwise specified. The jury will decide.
Washington Post Editors
September 14, 2010; 7:30 AM ET
Categories: Fairfax , Homicide , Reader Questions , Updates , Virginia
Save & Share: Previous: Prison after man's 8th alcohol arrest
Next: Diesel fuel stolen in Anne Arundel
Posted by: ennepe68 | September 14, 2010 11:51 AM | Report abuse
Posted by: christopher_a_metzler | September 16, 2010 2:07 AM | Report abuse