Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
On Twitter: dcsportsbog and PostSports  |  Facebook  |  E-mail alerts: Redskins and Sports  |  RSS

Strasburg the all-star, via Dibble and Dmitri Young

The Stephen Strasburg-for-all-star question keeps being raised across the country, and the answers are mixed. Dusty Baker and Joe Morgan both said no this week in interviews with FanHouse, with both arguing Strasburg doesn't have enough innings or results to make a case.

"How 'bout let's go with who deserves it?" Baker said. "Isn't that what the All-Star team is supposed to be about? I'm still an idealist."

Rob Dibble has gone in the other direction, writing on that if you want to win the game -- and home-field advantage -- you have to select Strasburg.

(Note: The above video from Strasburg's first start has nothing to do with the All-Star game. Or Strasburg, really. But it does include Albert Haynesworth fat jokes. I give it an A++++.)

Those arguments met in radio magic on Tuesday, when Dibble interviewed Dmitri Young on Sirius XM's MLB Network Radio. The first question concerned whether Strasburg deserved an all-star berth.

"No chance," Young said. "Reason being, he got called up in June. And granted, this kid is gonna be everything in this game, but there are guys that had to make rosters from Spring Training to finally get their chance and their opportunity. I feel that those guys would deserve it over the phenom. That's just my own opinion."

Jim Memolo then asked Young if he could find 10 better pitchers in the NL this season.

"That's another question." Dmitri replied. "That's a trick question right there. However, if I'm the manager, I would still look out for the guys that made it from day one out of Spring Training. I don't know if the commissioner's gonna step in or the union's gonna step in and make it any kind of issue, but me personally....I would not have Strasburg on the All-Star team."

And then Dibble brought the rhetoric. It was a winning moment.

"But here's the thing," he said. "The commissioner's already stepped in and added nine guys to the roster himself, so now there are 34 a side. You now have a permanent DH rule, you have a re-entry rule, and it's home-field advantage for the World Series. And you have one game to win. So I'll ask you the question again, would you put Strasburg on your team?"

"Tick, tock, tick, tock," Young said, while mulling the issue. "Yes, I would."

"See, that's the way i looked at it, Dmitri," the victorious Dibble said. "No, he doesn't merit the All-Star game, and [yes], the Strasburg mania is off the hook. But listen, pitching is a commodity and we need some good pitchers."

"Now I understand where you're coming from, if we're going from those merits," Young said. "But if we were going from the old format of the All-Star game, no."

And as long as we're quoting quotable people about Strasburg, here's what Ozzie Guillen said before Friday's game, via 106.7 The Fan. Guillen was asked whether he'd like to face Strasburg.

"I faced Clemens, bro," he said. "You know what I mean? I faced Clemens with his best stuff. I think this kid, there's no doubt, he's got one of the best stuff in the game right now. It's not a marketing thing. I watched a couple games, the guy was tough. I think he's got a chance to be a good one. It's one thing to me I think impressed [me] the most, is not the way he pitched, [it's] the way he's handled himself. With all this promotions and all this bullcrap around him. you know what I mean, handled himself very well, very professional."

And here's how Guillen judged Strasburg after he recorded the no-decision, via the Chicago Sun-Times:

'[Strasburg's] got good stuff,'' Guillen said. ''This kid knows how to pitch, and having 'Pudge' [catcher Ivan Rodriguez] behind the plate, that's a big help. After the first or second inning, he figured out we're pretty good. We can hit the fastball, and he stayed away from his fastball when it counted. He threw changeups to strike out guys. Pretty impressive.

''You don't see kids, no matter how good of stuff you have, to have that confidence on the mound. You don't find that everywhere. This is a pretty good one, but I think mine was better than him.''

Thing is, Ozzie, yours was pitching against the Nats.

By Dan Steinberg  |  June 22, 2010; 2:50 PM ET
Categories:  Media , Nats  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Cris Carter: Redskins had worst offseason in NFC
Next: Manute Bol remembered on Senate floor


Haynesworth is soooo fat when he puts on a Malcolm X shirt helicopters try to land on him.

Posted by: capsfan772 | June 22, 2010 3:13 PM | Report abuse

For the naysayers, I think this has more to do with a compulsion toward old-fashioned "paying your dues" than it does with choosing the best pitchers in the NL.

They're the same idiots who still think batting average and pitching "wins" are good measures of player performance.

Helicopter Strasburg to northern Canada and have him walk uphill both ways in the snow for a mile toward some school so that they can feel better about the world spinning out of control beneath them over this phenom coming onto the scene. Hopefully the hazing will satisfy them.

Posted by: B2O2 | June 22, 2010 5:57 PM | Report abuse

But Strasburg did EARN his way onto a roster out of Spring Training. He was just not placed on the team for financial and protective reasons. Should front office decisions related to finances keep him OFF the All-Star roster? To me, old school means that the All-Star game should be for those that have had the best half-seasons in baseball. Assuming he goes 5-0 or 5-1 with an ERA around 2 and is averaging a strikeout per inning, doesn't that qualify him for the All-Star game? Yes, what he has done so far doesn't, but he still has 4 games to go. People who are talking about him making the squad are projecting ahead, not just basing it on what he has done to this point in the season.

Posted by: Dougmacintyre | June 23, 2010 8:15 AM | Report abuse

Speaking of fat jokes, a list has been released of the Top 10 heaviest players in MLB history. It includes two current/former Nats, Adam Dunn and John Rauch, but inexplicably not Dmitri Young. Also somehow Prince Fielder did not make the list either, even though I'm SURE I saw the earth move when he singled and ended up on first next to Dmitri in a Nats-Brewers game a couple of years ago.

Why don't you look into that one, Steinberg?

Posted by: nunof1 | June 23, 2010 11:09 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company