In love with Twilight
I had never heard of Twilight until last month, when two tween granddaughters of a beloved cousin gave me an enthusiastic, hour-long summation of the four-book saga of love between a girl and a vampire. Our Readers Who Comment are way ahead of me. With the second Twilight movie about to open, they have filed serious, heartfelt criticism of both Stephanie Meyer's books and each other as they review Monica Hesse's fabulous story about how Twilight has surrounded the world. It's not just tweens doing the reading.
Hesse's story is getting the most readers on a day when we have many important hard-news events to absorb [health-care reform, mammograms, Afghanistan and the president in Asia], all of which are getting predictable comments.
The Twilight story has fewer comments, almost all of them are thoughtful. Is this because Our Readers want to be careful in engaging about a series that, as Hesse writes, "is a story about shame"?
We'll start with sql_yoda, who shouted, "...I LOVE VAMPIRE LORE! I'm a junkie, can't help it, never could. I couldn't get past the first twenty pages of Twilight. It SUCKS. It sucks so bad it's like a paginated vampire in a poor, deluded library..."
But Hailey_Baker86 said, "Thank you..I think regardless of what anyones opinion is of the books,that this was a fantastic piece. Exactly how I felt.
I never wanted to be addicted to twilight...but I couldn't help it. Once I started I was HOOKED!"
kadams00 wrote, "This was a fun little article, but I'd like to stand up as one of those women that can't possibly exist: one who's read all four books, seen the movie, and did not get sucked into the mania. I confess, I was afraid it might happen -- everyone was gobbling this stuff up. Still, I "chuckled" my way through the series..."
rja112 enthused, "Wow, a great article. I just might have to read the books now... Will I be swept up in the frenzy? Maybe not, since I am not a woman. But, you never know."
fallengoddess wrote, "...I feel some pity for the women profiled here - but ultimately, it's an unsupportable position. Everyone should feel free to like whatever they want, and no one should be ashamed of how something makes them feel, but none of that can make the Twilight books worth the paper they're written on. I read all four..."
donpersons said, "Nothing too surprising about any of it, including the "revelation"... that many intelligent, strong, capable women are vulnerable to fantasies of being dominated by "dazzling, chiseled" men, or just role-playing such with their partners.
How many enlightened, feminism-supporting men out there fantasize about playing master to their woman's wench? The allure is primal."
Dude_Angus wrote, "People need to chill out. Stop over analyzing everything. Some things are meant to just be fun. Not everything has to be Ayn Rand or Ernest Hemingway. Books and movies don't always have to be serious or artsy."
donpersons said, "fallengoddess and kadams, I'm reminded of an old Bloom County strip, with Opus the penguin sitting in his chair in front of tube saying, 'The quality of TV is really going downhill. The 8 hours I watched yesterday was horrible.'..."
wendymaloney1 wrote: "The Twilight series is a very poor modern example of the Gothic(k) novel. The prime target for this nonsense, teenage girls, are patronised both by 'Edward' and by Meyer. It is a shocking example of poor prose and 'dumbing down' the english language - shocking because it could have been just as popular with a little more rigour."
To which ci01 replied, "I know, I know. I'm an intelligent woman, with multiple degrees and a sucessful career.... the books are terrible... I own all four and I couldn't stop... this article cracked me up because I think most people recognize that they're garbage but, oh, such additctive garbage..."
cvsmith1 wrote, "My 13 year-old daughter has read this series a dozen times. She loves these books. I have never read them. I don't need to as she has shared nearly every detail!...This is a great bonding experience for us both!"
Yankeesfan1 said, "I have on occasion been labeled the strictest mom at our school. However I'll be taking my 12-year-old daughter to the midnight screening of New Moon despite the fact that it's a school night ..."
We'll close with mimi301, who wrote, "My husband cheerfully announced that there was a story about me on the front page of the Post. And he was right. Smug man..."
All comments on this article are here.
Posted by: modameister | November 19, 2009 2:32 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: theAnswerIs42 | November 19, 2009 2:24 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: ravitchn | November 19, 2009 1:50 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: intrepid122630yahoocom | November 19, 2009 1:38 PM | Report abuse
Posted by: GABinOdenton | November 19, 2009 10:47 AM | Report abuse
The comments to this entry are closed.