A Look Back at 1994
On Aug. 29, 1994, Adam Clymer, Robert Pear and Robin Toner published 6,500-word look at where health-care reform went wrong. It makes for interesting reading, both due to the similarities and the differences.
In the similarities column, an economic crisis consumes the first months of the new president's term. The hope of bipartisan cooperation proves a mirage, and the early ambitions buckle as the poll numbers drift down. The process takes longer than expected and the Senate angers the House by trimming its legislative sails.
But in the differences column, there's no Ira Magaziner this year. The process was much faster and the president elected with a significantly larger majority. Where Sen. Robert Byrd Jr. rejected reconciliation outright in 1994, the Obama White House convinced Senate Democrats to include the option into the 2009 budget. Sen. Max Baucus isn't the most popular guy in town this year, but unlike his Finance Committee predecessor, Pat Moynihan, he actually wants to pass a bill, not simply teach an impertinent president a lesson.
And the proof is in the committee process: In 1994, the various committees produced radically different bills, and a few of them failed altogether. Conversely, four committee have produced virtually identical bills this year, and a fifth is likely to finish work on a more modest, but not structurally different, bill in the next few weeks.
Related: My retrospective on the 1994 effort.
Posted by: bmull | September 21, 2009 10:25 AM | Report abuse
Posted by: Gray62 | September 21, 2009 10:28 AM | Report abuse
The comments to this entry are closed.