Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Posted at 1:27 PM ET, 03/16/2010

How can a jury get it so wrong?

By editors

By Dale Appleman

Regarding the March 13 Metro article “15-year sentence in N. Va. shooting”: Both blindfold and scales were stolen from the statue of justice. How can a jury get it so wrong?

The Fairfax County jury’s sentence of 15 years for second-degree murder was crushingly out of sync with the facts behind Evan D. Gargiulo’s killing of cabdriver Mazhar Nazir. The evidence showed that Mr. Gargiulo was an opportunistic passenger who hailed a taxi for a long ride after his wallet, cellphone and keys were stolen from a nightclub. Mr. Nazir took him from the District to Tysons Corner (to retrieve his car), with a stop first at his Reston apartment for the keys.

Is it surprising that after arriving at Tysons Corner, the driver was angry at learning his passenger now “realized” that the “roll of cash” stashed in his Halloween costume (a wetsuit) was also gone? Was the jury conscious when hearing that Mr. Gargiulo just happened to have picked up his 9mm gun along with his car keys at his apartment? Or that he called a friend from home afterward to say this was his “first civilian kill”? I cannot construct a clearer scenario of premeditation than the perpetrator’s decision to grab his gun along with his car keys.

And by the way, the taxi driver was born in Pakistan. Try reversing the characters in this nasty story and see whether you think a Pakistani-born 21-year-old would get off with 15 years for murdering a 49-year-old white American husband and father who had been a cabbie for 25 years. This sentence reflects the degree to which the jury’s sympathy for the wrong person has perverted justice.

By editors  | March 16, 2010; 1:27 PM ET
Categories:  Fairfax County, HotTopic, crime  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Who's the extremist here?
Next: One thing Metro could get right


Agreed and well said, I am very sorry for the family of Mazhar Nazir. Imagine being told your murdered loving patriarch was only worth 15 years in the eyes of the law. Shame on VA and Fairfax.

Posted by: mendelsonmustgo | March 17, 2010 12:45 PM | Report abuse

Indeed the jury did get it wrong. So sad.

Posted by: Renda23 | March 18, 2010 3:56 PM | Report abuse

Disagree, but well said. Judging from the posting and comments to it, one would think juries and trials are unnecessary. Give these writers the barest of facts, and they can tell what the "right" verdict should be.
Now, THAT's something to be ashamed of.

Posted by: Temper8 | March 19, 2010 5:57 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company