Niners Say Orthopedist Agrees With Initial Diagnosis that A. Smith Doesn't Need Surgery for Separated Shoulder

According to the San Francisco 49ers, orthopedic specialist James Andrews agreed with the initial diagnosis by the team's doctors that quarterback Alex Smith doesn't have to undergo surgery to repair his separated right shoulder.

Club officials denied an ESPN report that Smith sought a second opinion from Andrews and might have a serious injury requiring season-ending surgery. According to the 49ers, Andrews studied Smith's MRI exam results as a routine procedure.

The 49ers have indicated they might have a better idea by the end of this week how long Smith will be sidelined. Backup Trent Dilfer is to start this weekend's game against the Baltimore Ravens.

Smith was hurt during last weekend's loss to the Seattle Seahawks.

By Mark Maske |  October 4, 2007; 1:00 PM ET  | Category:  49ers
Previous: Panthers Have Players-Only Meeting | Next: Hearing in Vick Contract Case Done, Parties Told to Expect Ruling By End of Next Week

The comments to this entry are closed.