Talkin' Toys
It's still October and Halloween hasn't come and gone yet. And so, now's the perfect time to start talking toys for the holidays! If you're one of those readers who despises barely tolerates holiday decorations going up in stores on Nov. 1, you might want to click elsewhere.
Now, for the rest of you ready to talk toys ...
Earlier this month, Wal-Mart started cutting prices on toys. Last week, it announced price cuts on 15,000 more products with more price cuts coming. But will that get toy-buying parents to shop there?
Nearly 76 percent of U.S. consumers plan to buy toys that are not made in China this year. Will we do as we say? President and chief executive of polling company Zogby International, John Zogby's not so sure:
"Do they flip the toy around and do they look on the side of the box to see if it's made in China?" Zogby asked while noting that cost could ultimately be the deciding factory. Toys made in China cost significantly less than others and few consumers are planning to up their holiday spending budgets this year.
And if all the recalls on toys in China haven't already made you antsy about toy-buying, this Inc. interview with Summit Products president Dan Henderson just might. Henderson tells Inc. that random toy testing isn't really so random.
If you tell manufacturers, "Look, I want you to have something inspected," they can make sure that that particular piece doesn't have a problem. You hear stories.... With true random testing, the manufacturer doesn't have anything to do with selecting the sample."
Now, add to all the fears of lead a new ban on the chemical phthalate in California, and a trip to Wal-Mart, or Target, or Toys R Us might send you screaming out the door. Phthalates are a chemical plasticizer that makes plastic more flexible. The European Union and 14 other countries have banned phthalates after studies there found the chemical interferes with hormones and might lead to early puberty and other health problems including reproductive issues. A Consumer Product Safety Commission study in the late '90s found that children are not at risk from the chemical because of the low levels ingested.
What are your toy buying plans this holiday season? What's on your kids' wish lists? Are you planning to steer clear of Chinese products or are you confident that the products are getting safer?
By Stacey Garfinkle |
October 22, 2007; 7:15 AM ET
Previous: Panel: Restrict Child Cold Meds |
Next: When Something's Not Quite Right
Comments
Posted by: WorkingMomX | October 22, 2007 8:14 AM
| Report abuse
While its true that manufactuerer testing is not so random, the CPSC does do some random testing. This is mostly limited by the number of field inspectors (which has been cut drastcially over the past 5 years). But the field inspectors do go into stores and buy toys, just like you and I do. And there is some random sampling that happens at the ports, during import. But alas, this is a just a TINY percentage of the toys in America.
Posted by: RT | October 22, 2007 8:52 AM
| Report abuse
I am not sure what to believe. When Mattel did their big recall notice a few months back, I checked their entire list very carefully. I sent away for their recall brochure that listed date codes for the affected items. Even though my daughter had a large number of preschool/toddler toys on their list, none of the recall dates matched the ones actually being recalled. It was actually a small date range that made the recall list. So we kept the toys and I even checked her "big" Santa gift that I had previously bought. We are giving her Dora's Magical Castle. So I checked all the figures and furniture packs. None of them were being recalled. I did notice that Mattel has not seemed to find a new manufacturer for the parts because you can now purchase the castle and most of the furniture but not the characters. So I was very grateful we purchased this when toys r us had their summer blow out. My daughter used to stare at this every time we went to the toys r us store. Besides that my daughter is getting a lot of Strawberry shortcake dolls, fisher price little people, books and DVDs. She mostly likes dolls and small figures (so a lot of plastic). I do also buy American girl doll and the Canadian maplelea. But it is hard to get away with no China or no plastic. Again, we can only go on what the company is telling about recalls. Who knows how much is being affected. I wish everyone best of luck in shopping this year.
Posted by: foamgnome | October 22, 2007 9:18 AM
| Report abuse
Count me on the list for readers who despise it when retail starts putting up the christmas decorations prior to the day after Thanksgiving.
Fortunately, as far as presents go, family and friends are all big readers.
Posted by: David S | October 22, 2007 9:44 AM
| Report abuse
Although I bemoan early decorations, when my girls were younger, my goal was to have all Christmas shopping done by Thanksgiving (and I normally attained it!) That way you can truly enjoy the Christmas season without dread of things that need to be done.
Posted by: Barbara | October 22, 2007 10:03 AM
| Report abuse
I really wish (I think I have said this before) that there would be some care taken around recalls about whether the problem actually ORIGINATES in China or not.
Some does - the lead paint on the Thomas toys, for example, clearly was a problem with the Chinese manufacturer.
But a LOT of the recalls are DESIGN issues (magnets that can come loose), not MANUFACTURING issues. My impression is that US companies are issuing recalls now for these things in part because they can "blame China" for what is ultimately their problem - a lack of attention to design.
So for me, I will be looking at the individual toys, manufacturer's records overall, materials used, and then perhaps country of origin.
Our favourites for this year for my toddler are Plan toys (Brio trains, and the big gift he's getting is the plan wooden dollhouse & accessories). In the future we're looking to Playmobil, but planning to buy as much as possible used.
Posted by: shandra_lemarath | October 22, 2007 10:18 AM
| Report abuse
Nearly 76 percent of U.S. consumers plan to buy toys that are not made in China this year.
Since 76 percent of US consumers could not point out China on a map, i would not read too much into this.
Posted by: pATRICK | October 22, 2007 10:47 AM
| Report abuse
Unless parents are planning not to buy any toys for Christmas, they'll be buying stuff made in China. If you look at the fine print, almost everything is.
Posted by: Rockville Mom | October 22, 2007 11:07 AM
| Report abuse
National Wildlife Federation's magazines make great year-round gifts, and since they're non profit, it's a tax write-off.
Posted by: WDC 21113 | October 22, 2007 11:08 AM
| Report abuse
Not so fast! There is no way you can deduct the subscription cost as a tax write off. If you receive goods or services from a non profit, you have to deduct the fair market value of the item or service before arriving at a deductible amount. In this case, the cost of the goods (your subscription) IS the fair market value of the item!
====
National Wildlife Federation's magazines make great year-round gifts, and since they're non profit, it's a tax write-off.
Posted by: Death and Taxes | October 22, 2007 11:23 AM
| Report abuse
I haven't even considered Christmas gifts yet. I don't even have a handle on Halloween yet.
Would I prefer to buy non-Chinese manufactured toys? Probably. My 4 year old son likes books, Thomas/Brio wooden trains, Legos, Tinker Toys, Lincoln Logs,K'Nex and plain old ordinary building blocks. I don't actually know where these toys come from. I know some of the wooden toys are actually European-made, but they're quite expensive.
I suspect checking eBay might be a good way to build his collections without draining my pocketbook. And I have the added bonus of recycling.
Either way, I'm not even going to think about Christmas presents, decorations, or parties until after November 1st... maybe later.
Posted by: MadisonMom | October 22, 2007 11:48 AM
| Report abuse
Costco had their Christmas decorations up in September.
Posted by: Ryan | October 22, 2007 12:54 PM
| Report abuse
My goal this year is recycled toys - nothing new, uless it's books. For the adults who have everything, I'm buying Hunger Mercy Kits that feed starving children - I'm so sick of the junk I get and give every year. If I must give a tangible gift, I'm buying from the Breast Cancer Store where every purchase goes to a worthy cause.
Posted by: Marti | October 22, 2007 1:02 PM
| Report abuse
Tinker Toys are actually made in China - I checked...
Posted by: Jennifer | October 22, 2007 1:48 PM
| Report abuse
Legos
Legos
Legos
Legos
Legos
Legos
Legos
that's all they want
Posted by: Anonymous | October 22, 2007 2:18 PM
| Report abuse
No I don't really care- I know their mother keeps a close eye on the recall lists so she will tell me what not to buy, otherwise I just try and spoil them as much as I possibly can.
Posted by: Liz D | October 22, 2007 2:23 PM
| Report abuse
My son loves legos, and since those are made in Europe, I assume those are okay. I've been meaning to get a lead-testing kit to test the hot wheels and polly pockets we have. I would bet that we have at least one toy in our house that's contaminated with lead. I would love to avoid toys made in China, but I fear that it will be impossible.
Posted by: Arlington, VA | October 22, 2007 4:17 PM
| Report abuse
A lot of stores here already have their stores decorated for Christmas, too. It's revolting.
We have decided to spend much, much less on Christmas gifts this year. We already bought a giant tub of Lincoln Logs for my 2-yo son. (Just now checked, and yes, made in China.) When all is said and done, that may be all we do buy. We had the same experience as WorkingMomX last year. Not doing it again, especially when we can't afford to anyway. Honestly, at his age he prefers going to the park over getting a new toy.
As for my SILs 7 kids, they always get so much at Christmas.. Instead of wasting my money on stuff they really don't want or need, this year I am sewing each of them a couple pairs pajama pants, with personalized labels inside.
Posted by: Karen in AL | October 22, 2007 4:26 PM
| Report abuse
I am not buying toys made in China. If you think there are no toys that were not made in China, you're not looking very hard. For example, Oompa Toys ( http://www.oompa.com/ ) has a whole section of "Made in Europe" toys. Yes, they cost more. But do our kids really need 50+ toys anyway? I'd rather have a smaller number of quality, safe toys than a bunch of plastic junk.
The other way to approach it is to give your children experiences - trips out to the zoo, a baseball game, etc. They will cherish these a lot more than presents that end up as piles of junk.
Posted by: Mary in FL | October 23, 2007 12:07 PM
| Report abuse
The comments to this entry are closed.











I am already done shopping for the kids, if you can believe it. The last of my orders came in on Friday. I still have to shop for everyone else, but half the battle's won, anyhow.
I also deliberately downsized this year. Last year, it seemed like they had so many gifts, they didn't know what to do with themselves after they'd opened everything. Overwhelming.
I tend to buy stuff that I can resell later. Playmobil, for example, has a great resale value. My son is just starting to get into Lionel trains and Santa will be bringing a few things to help him create his own "train garden". My daughter loves dolls. It is pretty much impossible to avoid buying stuff that comes from China, in whole or in part, unless you cut a tree down in your backyard, sand the logs yourself, and make wooden toys.