Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity

How Afghans see Obama's withdrawal deadline

In The Post this week, I argue that Obama’s July, 2011 withdrawal deadline in Afghanistan is undermining our counterinsurgency strategy, because Afghans will not risk joining us in the fight if they think America will soon be leaving them to the mercy of the Taliban. The New York Times now confirms the effect the deadline is having on the battlefield. Peter Baker notes that Obama has in recent days sought to add nuance to the deadline, but:

that part of the message has not transmitted to many in the rural reaches of Afghanistan, where American troops regularly encounter Afghans who assume they are all leaving next year. In the village of Abdul Ghayas in Helmand Province last month, for example, a local resident exasperated two Marines when he told them that he was nervous about helping with their plans for a new school out of fear that the Taliban would retaliate after the Americans went home next year. "That’s why they won’t work with us," Cpl. Lisa Gardner, one of the Marines, told a reporter traveling with the unit. "They say you’ll leave in 2011 and the Taliban will chop their heads off. It’s so frustrating."

If millions of Afghans are coming to the same conclusion, and deciding not to work with the coalition for fear of retribution, the surge cannot possibly succeed.

Afghans have good reasons for their mistrust. They have not forgotten how the U.S. helped them defeat the Soviet Union in the 1980s, only to withdraw -- allowing the Taliban to impose its brutal rule, with mass executions in soccer stadiums and bans on girls going to school and children flying kites. As one intelligence official told the Times, “They’ve been burned, and they’ve seen this movie before.”

When they hear the president talk about withdrawal, Afghans don’t hear his promises not to “run for the exits” -- they think to themselves, “here we go again.” And who can blame them?

In Washington, we watch for small shifts in presidential rhetoric and divine large shifts in policy. Not in Afghanistan. A villager deciding whether to work with American forces in Helmand province does not follow to subtle nuances of Obama’s words. His memory and his ears tell him America is leaving soon. The president needs to send a clear message to that villager and the millions like him across Afghanistan that we will not abandon them to the Taliban a second time. The only way to do that is to repudiate his withdrawal deadline -- clearly and unequivocally -- and to begin making clear his resolve to prevail.

By Marc Thiessen  | June 30, 2010; 11:00 AM ET
Categories:  Thiessen  | Tags:  Marc Thiessen  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: What Kagan should have said
Next: Elena Kagan: the great comedienne


You really have to ask, what in Obama's experience could have led him to believe that anouncing an intention to withdraw from Afghanistan next year would help the military or encourage those prepared to ally themselves with us in Afghanistan?

Even a man whose entire adult experience took place in academia and community organizing circles might have thought better of that.

Posted by: Roytex | June 30, 2010 12:14 PM | Report abuse

Even a man whose entire adult experience took place in academia and community organizing circles might have thought better of that.

Posted by: Roytex


Not when his primary focus is on his reelection and placating his left-wing base who thought the war was lost a long time ago. Then it makes perfect sense.

Posted by: bbface21 | June 30, 2010 12:28 PM | Report abuse

Please this makes no sense. Just because someone else started this mess does not mean Americans should continue to die.

Posted by: rlj1 | June 30, 2010 1:41 PM | Report abuse

We need to quit interfering in foreign governments. The more we do, the more enemies we make.

Posted by: caljen1701 | July 1, 2010 11:11 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company