Live Last Night: The Hold Steady/Art Brut/1990s

My review of last night's Hold Steady gig at the sold-out 9:30 club? Right here. It was pretty much the same show as last year's - almost identical setlist, same speech at the end, my same complaints about singer Craig Finn missing the timing on some of his best lines - but I enjoyed it slightly more. Maybe I was just in a good mood thanks to Andray Blatche's breakout game for the Wizards, I don't know.

Two new songs played last night showed that the band doesn't plan on changing things up any time soon. "Stay Positive" was a riff showcase for guitarist Tad Kubler and it's as if Finn took all of his previously existing lyrics, put them in a hat, randomly pulled out phrases and created a new song out of it. "Ask Her for Adderall" brought another prescription pill into the Hold Steady universe; "Krazy for Klonopin" can't be far behind.

The one thing I feel very strongly about is that Finn should ditch his guitar and concentrate solely on vocal duties. Half the time he's simply wearing the guitar as an adornment anyway. When he's free to roam the stage and spit out his lyrics while his hands do whatever they do, everything clicks so much better. Anyone else agree with me on this point?

It's hard not to be won over by Art Brut's goofy enthusiasm and their catchy art-punk anthems. But the fact remains that you need to own exactly one of their albums (last year's "Bang Bang Rock and Roll") and you need to see them live exactly once. After that it's just overkill. Lead singer Eddie Argos is an entertaining fellow, even when you have no clue what he's saying (thick accent + muddy sound), and his mid-set pogoing from the stage to the back of the club was good for a laugh. He's clearly been going to the Bob Pollard School of Microphone Twirling and has been scoring solid Bs in his courses. The band had a video screen behind them that showed the song title and occasional quips. When Argos announced they would be playing "I Will Survive" the screen flashed "NOT A COVER." I half expected Argos to launch into The Word at some point.

Because of 1990s' (no The, please) Franz Ferdinand connections and their single "You're Supposed to Be My Friend" I was expecting a bit more dance-punk to their sound. But there was as much more T. Rex in the mix, and that was a good thing. The trio's sound was a bit thin at times, although that may have just been the result of playing in a very large, half-filled club. Plenty of songs about drugs and debauchery -- the theme for the night. Solid songs, solid performance.

And now instead of rambling on more, let's play a little game. It's inspired by my favorite local music blog DC Rock Club. Those dudes like to find celebrities that look like members of bands, so here's what I came up with for the singers of last night's three bands. I know the formatting is awful, but you get the point. It's a long holiday weekend, what do you want? Pictures after the jump.

Actor Tim Curry +

Triple Crown winner Secretariat =

1990s singer Jackie McKeown.

Actor Steve Coogan +

Actor Alfred Molina =

Art Brut singer Eddie Argos. politics blogger Chris Cillizza =

Hold Steady singer Craig Finn (far left).

By David Malitz |  November 21, 2007; 3:21 PM ET Hold Steady , Live Last Night
Previous: The A-to-Z Hold Steady Glossary | Next: The Two-Minute Man, Episode 2


Please email us to report offensive comments.

Um, the "right here" link takes me to your underwhelmed 2006 review, David.

Posted by: polly | November 21, 2007 4:35 PM

Yeah that was sorta the point, Polly. It was pretty much the same show, except this time Tad jumped off the balcony. Which was pretty excellent, I must admit. Man did those pictures mess up the formatting!

Posted by: David | November 21, 2007 4:56 PM

Gotcha, thanks. My literal gene kicked in. You'd think they'd retool the set list at least with so many months in between.

Posted by: polly | November 21, 2007 6:30 PM

Excellent picks for the celebrity look alikes. Tim Curry and Secretariat is fantastic. I can't top that. We said Eddie Argos looks like Bryan Ferry (when both sported a 'stache) but your combo wins the top prize.

Now I just need to figure how who the keyboardist from the Hold Steady looks like. Chef Boyardee? All the Village People wrapped into one? Damn, it shouldn't be that hard...

PS - sorry to hear about Gilbert.

Posted by: Jumbo Slice | November 22, 2007 5:02 PM

I thought The Hold Steady keyboardist had been replaced by Super Mario.

Posted by: angryelvis | November 27, 2007 8:36 AM

Steve Coogan and Alfred Molina - you must have seen Coffee & Cigarettes recently!

I think the Hold Steady need a rhythm guitarist. Tad can't do all the guitar work on his own. It doesn't have to be Craig Finn - they could hire someone just for touring.

Posted by: SSMD | November 27, 2007 10:46 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.


© 2010 The Washington Post Company