I Don't Listen to My Morning Jacket Anymore Now That They Are Popular
OK, that title is a bit misleading but the basics are true. My Morning Jacket used to be a pretty obscure band. During that time I liked them very much. Now they are a very popular band, one that can sell out a 3,500 seat venue like Constitution Hall (tonight) and be a headliner at a mega-festival like Bonnaroo. And I've lost interest. Some people would like to peg this strictly as indie snobbery. But that's not exactly the case. Below I'll outline the reasons MMJ isn't on the top of my "must see" list any more.
Their early albums are better/More the style that I like.
This one is simple enough. My Morning Jacket started off as a spaced-out alt-country band on "The Tennessee Fire" before landing at some mid-point between peak era Wilco and Flaming Lips on "At Dawn," which remains my favorite MMJ album. I listened to those two albums so much I was bound to be burned out on the band. But when they followed that up with the increasingly jammy, Southern-rock inflected "It Still Moves" (which, admittedly, has the band's best song, "Mageetah") I started to lose interest. Then came the synth-heavy and over-produced "Z" and, to paraphrase J. Freedom's chat intro, whatever it is that "Evil Urges" is. The band started at one place on the musical spectrum and moved somewhere else. Good for them for trying out new things, no sense staying stagnant, but those new things just weren't up my alley.
I've already seen them enough, and in smaller places.
I think we can all agree that seeing a band in a small venue is almost always preferable to seeing them in a bigger setting. I was lucky enough to catch My Morning Jacket at the tiny, now-defunct Metro Café twice as they toured behind "At Dawn." The first time there were maybe a dozen people there. This didn't stop MMJ from going all out. It remains one of the loudest shows I've ever been to, with everything turned up to 11, except the reverb which was at approximately 49. Jim James was barefoot and thrashing his hair like he was playing for thousands and the band played a full two hours. It was a simply monstrous show. The second time around the club was a little more crowded, but it still felt like a private show by one of the country's best bands. As the band worked its way up the ladder to the Black Cat then the 9:30 club, the shows remained excellent but weren't quite as special. At this point I've seen the band six times and it's never going to be as good as seeing them in a small club playing all the songs off my favorite album. Since My Morning Jacket doesn't quite fit with the Pope Theory, I'll pass.
They don't need me anymore.
Now here's where you can start making your indie snob argument, but I'll try to convince why it doesn't exactly work. For us socially awkward folk who are far too obsessed with music, we feel like we have co-dependent relationships with our favorite bands. In place of, you know, friends, we have our bands. We need them. So, right or wrong, we like to feel that they need us. Back when I was one of a dozen or so people watching My Morning Jacket at the Metro Café, it was easy to feel a certain connection with the band. The $10 I paid to see them that night, they needed that to help them get to the next city to rock for the 30 or 40 people who would see them there. Those constant spins on the college radio station to help made them chart in CMJ, that helped them as well. I don't begrudge the band their current success; in a weird way I feel like I helped them get there.
But now they don't need me, so I don't really need them. No hard feelings, just that there are bands playing for 12 people that need me more. You could say the mindset is almost like those crazy ladies who take in stray cats and then put them up for adoption once they're deemed fit and healthy. So next time you find someone who stopped liking a band that started small but made it big automatically assume it's only because it's a reaction to popularity.
Because then you might get some defensive, babbling 750 word response trying to convince you otherwise.
Please email us to report offensive comments.
Posted by: Hemisphire | September 3, 2008 5:55 PM
Posted by: Jet Age Eric | September 3, 2008 6:17 PM
Posted by: SSMD | September 4, 2008 9:36 AM
Posted by: msto | September 4, 2008 10:34 AM
Posted by: Floyd | September 4, 2008 12:04 PM
Posted by: Adam | September 4, 2008 2:04 PM
Posted by: wolff | September 4, 2008 2:28 PM
Posted by: polly | September 4, 2008 2:42 PM
Posted by: MN | September 4, 2008 3:02 PM
Posted by: Malitz | September 4, 2008 5:29 PM
Posted by: SolShine7 | September 11, 2008 7:11 PM
The comments to this entry are closed.