Computer Science Professor, Former FCC Official Warns Against Net Neutrality
There are too many lawyers talking about net neutrality and not enough engineers; this was the message by a panel of computer science experts, a law professor and an economist Friday morning. They mostly warned against the potential constraints that net neutrality rules would have on network engineering.
David Farber, a professor of computer science and policy at Carnegie Mellon, said the FCC's proposal for new net neutrality rules could hamper innovation on the Web. Farber, who runs a popular e-mail list on technology issues and is a former chief technology officer for the FCC, said that Internet networks have always prioritized certain traffic and that new rules proposed by the Federal Communication Commission to try to stop discrimination on cable, DSL and wireless networks could constrain operators and tech companies from properly managing their networks.
Farber, who spoke on a panel about net neutrality at the think tank Information Technology & Innovation Foundation, called the discussions around net neutrality "religious debates" that haven't taken into consideration the technological challenges faced by engineers, particularly those building the next generation of services for mobile broadband. Farber co-penned a piece in 2007 that criticized net neutrality.
"We have to create an environment where innovation is possible," he said via a online video feed into ITIF's offices. "The marketplace determines what is acceptable or not, and so far that has gotten us a long way."
Such concerns are expected to be part of the FCC's review of network management practices, Colin Crowell, a senior adviser at the FCC, has said. When FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski introduces the proposal Oct. 22, a process will begin to explore complicated questions of what kinds of network management are reasonable for network operators.
September 25, 2009; 1:41 PM ET
Previous: Worth Reading: Fast Forward Opines, Breaks Down Net Neutrality | Next: Update: AT&T Accuses Google of Violating Telecom Laws; Google Rejects Claims
Get This Widget >>
Blogs That Reference This Entry
TrackBack URL for this entry:
Please email us to report offensive comments.
Posted by: Computer_Forensics_Expert_Computer_Expert_Witness | September 25, 2009 9:42 PM
Posted by: squirma | September 26, 2009 7:10 PM