Antidepressants no more effective than placebos, leading researcher claims in new book

By Steven Levingston

Antidepressants are little more than placebos, argues a new book on sale this week, adding to a long-brewing controversy over the drugs' effectiveness and raising questions about how America treats patients suffering from mental illness.

Irving Kirsch, a psychologist who has researched placebos and antidepressants for more than a decade and co-authored a seminal study in 1998, discovered after reviewing drug company data that there was little difference between the effects of antidepressants and the effects of placebos.

In "The Emperor's New Drugs: Exploding the Antidepressant Myth," Kirsch extends the argument to the nature of depression and its treatment. After years of assessing the clinical studies, he rejects the conventional belief that depression is caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain that drugs can fix. "The belief that antidepressants can cure depression chemically is simply wrong," he writes.

Kirsch, a professor of psychology at the University of Hull in Britain, was early and vocal in his skepticism about drug companies' claims for antidepressants. His 1998 study, conducted when he was at the University of Connecticut and co-authored with Guy Sapirstein, examined the improvement of patients taking antidepressants with that of patients given placebos. The authors found that the placebos gave patients about three-quarters of the improvement experienced by patients on the drugs.

In the book, Kirsch discusses not only published data but also studies that were withheld by drug companies. About 40 percent of the companies' clinical trials for specific drugs were withheld, and "by and large," Kirsch writes, "these were studies that had failed to show a significant benefit from taking the actual drug."

The book explores how critics tried over the years to discredit Kirsch's studies and how he dug deeper into the data. He also explains how placebos work and argues for treatments that steer clear of chemicals. "Depression is a serious problem, but drugs are not the answer," he writes. "In the long run, psychotherapy is both cheaper and more effective, even for very serious levels of depression."

By Steven E. Levingston |  February 4, 2010; 5:30 AM ET Politics , Steven Levingston
Previous: Poet's Choice: "Money Talks" by Rae Armantrout | Next: The best political fiction and nonfiction of all time


Please email us to report offensive comments.

Yeah....ya know what buddy? Go jump in a river. I have a couple of friends who would be dead without their mediaction.

Posted by: EricS2 | February 4, 2010 9:58 AM

The Physicians Desk Reference states that SSRI antidepressants and all antidepressants can cause mania, psychosis, abnormal thinking, paranoia, hostility, etc. These side effects can also appear during withdrawal. Also, these adverse reactions are not listed as Rare but are listed as either Frequent or Infrequent.

Go to where there are over 3,600 cases, with the full media article available, involving bizarre murders, suicides, school shootings/incidents [52 of these] and murder-suicides - all of which involve SSRI antidepressants like Prozac, Zoloft, Paxil, etc, . The media article usually tells which SSRI antidepressant the perpetrator was taking or had been using.

Posted by: Rosiecee | February 4, 2010 10:06 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.


© 2010 The Washington Post Company