Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Posted at 11:05 PM ET, 06/ 3/2010

Israeli special missions veteran deplores raid plan

By Jeff Stein

A second Israeli special operations veteran has denounced his government’s handling of the boarding operation in international waters off Gaza.

Mike Eldar spent two decades in the Israeli navy, which included the command of an amphibious special missions unit, Shayetet 11, during the 1982 invasion of Lebanon. He later wrote books about that and another elite unit, Shayetet 13, the same navy commandos sent to intercept the aid mission Monday night.

Like Victor Ostrovsky, the former Israeli navy and Mossad operations officer interviewed by SpyTalk earlier this week, Eldar said the tactics used to neutralize the flotilla headed for Gaza made no sense.

“I cannot explain it,” he said by phone from Israel. “The only explanation is stupidity, super egos.”

“Mossad should have certainly had agents aboard the ships,” he said, to advise the commandos on how to proceed, “but if they did, then how can we explain this fiasco?”

But Eldar, 64, rejected Ostrovsky’s view that the botched operation, which resulted in scores of civilian casualties and nine dead, including an American citizen of Turkish origin, was rushed to accommodate orders from Israel's civilian leadership.

“It was not a rush job,” said Eldar, who was also involved in the navy's clandestine “Ghost Winds” sabotage raids against Palestinian ships during his career. “They had at least two weeks to prepare, with lots of practice. It was not a hasty attack.”

The code name for Monday’s nighttime mission, “Sky Winds 7,” meant that it had been preceded by six other seaborne operations, Eldar said -- but with a crucial difference: Those missions would have involved boarding hostile cargo ships manned by small crews, perhaps 15 seamen and officers combined. In contrast, the this week's flotilla included hundreds of passengers, most of them Turks.

Although there were certainly hostile elements aboard the ships -- “shahid, Islamic martyrs who wanted to die,” Eldar called them -- Monday’s mission called for entirely different tactics, he said.

“They have other systems. I don’t know why they didn’t use them,” he said.

Like Ostrovsky, who spent six years in the navy before being recruited by Mossad, Eldar said the Israelis should have just disabled the ships’ propellers “and let the Turks bring them food and water.”

“It would be no problem for the frogmen and their equipment,” he said.

Instead, the raid turned into a “fiasco” when the black-clad commandos descended out of the darkness onto the top decks from roaring helicopters -- many armed with only paint guns “to show they came with good will,” Eldar scoffed. Their arrival sparked a pitched battle.

“It should have ended in a reasonable way,” he said. “Instead bad people are being received in Turkey like heroes, and we are the bad guys.”

Eldar said Defense Minister Ehud Barak, a former head of special operations himself, who would have had overall responsibility for the raid, “should consider resigning.”

But no heads will roll, he ventured. “Even if someone is held accountable, no one will be sacked. They’ll say, ‘You fought bravely, you did your mission.’”

Indeed, Barak congratulated the unit Thursday.

“I have come in the name of the Israeli government to say 'Thank you,'" the defense minister told the soldiers at their base in Atlit, according to Israel News.

"You operated under difficult conditions and carried out your mission to prevent the flotilla from reaching Gaza,” Barak was quoted as saying. “I trust all of the commanders here to investigate the operation in order to draw the necessary lessons for the next time.”

By Jeff Stein  | June 3, 2010; 11:05 PM ET
Categories:  Intelligence, Military  | Tags:  Ehud Barak, Mike Eldar  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   Del.icio.us   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Backchannel chatter: Spymasters surface nearby
Next: Ex-top CIA-FBI official: Miranda never hurt us

Comments

Obviously, a deeper reason behind this Shayetet-13 commando idiotic mockery of itself for international scrutiny is highly unlikely the think tank mind set of the Israeli's and world's finest " Shayetet 13, navy commandos, Mossad operations officers and IDF command."

--The Israeli elite unit, Shayetet 13, navy commandos sent to intercept an aid mission Monday night via flotilla headed for Gaza blundered in a near failure.

What appears to be the Israeli Special-ed Forces operation known as the Sky Winds 7 mission on a flotilla raid that turned into a “fiasco” of odds..

When the black-clad commandos descended out of the darkness of night sky onto the top decks from thunder claps of roaring helicopters with many IDF personnel armed with only paint guns “to show they came with good will."

This resulting in IDF soldiers nearly getting killed by mercenary's mix with civilians,
Intelligence (?).

I have brain damage, and a sleuth of other mental limitations and went to special-ed classes all my life and here we are.

I can obviously see a mentally slow simple mind's eye approach here that fails the IQ test of rational military SunTzu reasoning and strategy.

The many high profile strategist of intelligence agencies may very well express a different approach, but never this simple minded without rational ulterior motives.

Perhaps placing the enemy at ease, and giving them a pride full laugh for a week or so and then....

The IDF made this performance for a reason. Most to all people are in the box thinkers but not the IDF.

Whatever the news media is televised there is most always an answer hidden and not entirely on the same track as presented.

-A primary decisive strike is more then likely Israel's next move unknown to it's enemy target and whichever that maybe, but I shall guess Iran and a few other places perhaps.

This is, will be a big operation. Good luck breeders and do not forget your nukes allied forces...


...
Shawn Earnest
Madawaska Maine
An Aspiring Fictional Writer.
---

Posted by: SSF_Predator_Hunter | June 6, 2010 11:25 PM | Report abuse

I've come across a curious investigation, carried out by some Israeil historian named Schlomo Sand (here's the wiki-article about him — http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schlomo_Sand). He considers the roots of the conflict to lie at the the so-called "deadend of the national mythologization".

I've come to know about the guy here — http://www.win.ru/en/ideas/4549.phtml

Posted by: last_boy_scout | June 7, 2010 8:19 AM | Report abuse

The comments to this entry are closed.

 
 
RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company