Network News

X My Profile
View More Activity
Lisa's Favorite Sites
Posted at 5:30 AM ET, 03/ 3/2011

'American Idol' 2011: Top 12 girls perform

By Lisa de Moraes
Julie Zorrilla performs in front of the judges. (Fox)

The Top-12 chicks sing for 5 spots on "American Idol" tonight.

Ta-Tynisa Wilson attempts Rihanna's "Only Girl (In the World)." Well, anyway, she's leggy. Actually, her legs are stronger than her voice. On lower register she fades out almost completely.

New judges Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez like her for reasons they don't quite pinpoint. I mean, "the song sang you - you sang the song beautifully"? Really Tyler? But Randy, reading from his Simon In My Mind playbook - specifically, the chapter entitled, "What Would Simon Say?" -- announces: "I got a feeling this is going to happen a lot this season -- I kinda differ from them" and proceeds to speak the truth: Ta-Tynisa's performance was nothing special. "Being a good performer is about moving the crowd and she moved the crowd," JLo snaps back at Randy. JLo, sweetie, we're talking about the "Idol" crowd here -- they're as movable as cardboard boxes.

Naima Adedapo takes a conventionally jazzy approach to "Summertime" -- a song that should be banned from "Idol" because we're sick of the Fantasia comparisons. On the bright side, Naima is dressed as a banana - designed the costume herself, she tells show host Ryan Seacrest. JLo mistakes the banana for an "exotic flower." Naima says her name means "exotic flower." What are the odds? Tyler thinks she's "early Ella Fitzgerald."

We want to like Kendra Chantelle, but her "Impossible" is not memorable. Frankly, she needs to develop a more dangerous image if wants to sing Christina Aguilera numbers. The leather pants just don't cut it -- we think maybe a tattoo is called for. Tyler, on the other hand, raves about her "voice hot, clothes hot, style hot," while JLo likes her "heart." See, that's the difference between men and women judges.

Thia Megia performs. (Fox)

Rachel Zevita launches into Fiona Apple tune "Criminal" while tossing off her black wrap, brushing aside the microphone, and staging a Judges Table Runaround -- a maneuver usually not tried by "Idol" contestants till later in the competition. Rachel falls behind schedule and has to keep singing while running back up the steps (don't try this at home) to to her mark on stage for the final notes.

It's all too weird and, according to Tyler "too Broadway." "I think that's the one thing I've never sung," Rachel retorts, which leaves Tyler speechless. "It didn't work," Randy concludes. "Now I know why you didn't make it to Hollywood Week that other season," Simon Cowell tells her -- in our head.

Karen Rodriguez does a Miss America-competition version of Mariah Carey's feel-better-about-yourself song "Hero." But Karen's got a twist, performing it in English and Spanish! It's a button-pushing move that successfully knocks out the judges.

"Wow! Wow! Wow! Wow!"says JLo, adding, "it showed who you are and what your flavor is". Randy: "you made it your own with that." Tyler: "You're one of a kind!" Karen will run straight back to her room and started translating bits of "My Heart Will Go On" and "I Will Always Love You" into Spanish. It's moments like this that miss Simon Cowell most. What would Simon have said? "You did sound like Mariah Carey -- with a head cold."

We're inclined to like Lauren Turner because of the whole house cleaner background and when she comes out singing about a hard working woman with "Seven Day Fool," the Etta James number, she had us at whatever was the first chore in the lyrics. Lauren has a good strong bluesy voice and a likeable delivery, but please get her a new wardrobe consultant.

Ashthon Jones has got attitude, she's got head bob, she's got swagger, she's got a great figure, a beautiful face, incredible hair. Unfortunately, she also has to sing. She can't handle Monica's "Love All Over Me." Because she's got all the diva trappings, but not much of a voice. And we can't shake the feeling she's ordering us to like her.

"You've got the confidence of a queen, and you sing so sweet," Tyler says, predictably, while JLo congratulates her on having all "the makings of a diva" and suggests she needs to ditch the Monica and go for Diana Ross. We resist the urge to gag. "Its' cool, but I think you're broader and bigger than that," Randy says. No, she's not.

Dressed in another of her fabulous party dresses, Julie Zorrilla looks ever more like the chick the other Girldolettes try to trip when she walks by. The producers can't trot her out with out nudging us all that she's supposed to be the winner. She's pretty and poised but when she gets on stage her performance of "Breakaway" is too pretty and poised. She makes a strategic mis-step in choosing a song by Ur-Idolette Kelly Clarkson, and gets kicked for it by Randy, who lies in wait for anyone who doesn't different-up on a cover song.

Naima Adedapo performs. (Fox)

"You didn't bring anything different or new," he tells her. Tyler agrees it was the "wrong song for you" and would have been better if she "took it up a couple keys"-- which would have put her in James Durbin territory.

Haley Reinhart's performance of "Fallin'," the slow-moving Alicia Keys song, works well enough but only reinforces our suspicion that this is going to be the guys' season on "Idol."

Anyway, Randy -- still with Simon In His Mind, is down on her and it; "didn't do anything for you" he says and "almost like a karaoke thing". We want to know what karaoke club Randy hangs out at, because they must not let just anybody take the mike. Anyway, he seems a bit abashed when the other judges contradict him.

Thia Megia, though just 15, has more guts than the others: she sings with just with a piano to back her up, instead of the usual "Idol" full-band-and-chorus safety net. The song, "Out Here On MY Own" is from "Fame" - the "Glee" of its day. It's a smart choice for this high schooler to come out and do a poignant girl's song.

Lauren Alaina's got a powerful voice, great phrasing, no jitters, and is just 16. She's sometimes hard to hear as she sings "Turn on the Radio," what with the ear splitting accompaniment of the "Idol" house band's wall of sound. But in the moments when the band takes a break to catch its breath, she sounds great. Did we mention she's just 16? The judges heap her with praise - most particularly Randy who describes her as a cross between Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. And then, Lauren introduces us to "Peaches" - who is, in fact Seabiscuit. He's from Georgia - she is too. A new nickname is born.

Pia Toscano wraps things up with a version of "I'll Stand By You" that's as polished and smooth as the performance of Karen Rodriguez who we saw earlier and - hey, wait a minute, aren't they the two Girldolettes who attended the performing arts high school in New York? Of course, they both spent hours polishing delivery in shop class! Unlike Karen, she obviously didn't take Bilingual Lyric Singing Class so she's not really "making this her own," as the judges might say, but she's building The Pretenders tune up and up, to a very big finish that's loud and sustained enough to wake even Charlie Sheen in the morning.

The judges are up on their feet and applauding. "After a Monday and a Tuesday, even a week says WTF!" Tyler observes. OMG - has Tyler hired Ellen DeGeneres to write his "Idol" judging comments in advance? And the roar from the audience appears to have blown the whole Simon In His Mind clean out of Randy's head, because he begins to gush: "Yo, this is our first Standing O of this new season Idol 10! I've been here 10 seasons and we've had some amazing performances, but let me tell you something, you just put yourself in the top with those amazing performances that have gone on to do amazingly good things!"

Okay, she was good but - did we miss something? Was that really up there in the Great Moments in "Idol" History? Well, one thing's for certain: Julie Zorilla can breathe a sigh of relief because the other girls won't be trying to trip her any more.

By Lisa de Moraes  | March 3, 2011; 5:30 AM ET
Categories:  "American Idol"  
Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati   Google Buzz   Previous: Charlie Sheen plays yet another role in Scorched Earth Media Tour
Next: 'Two and a Half Men' star Jon Cryer: "This is a trainwreck"


Every year, I say the same thing - why don't the vocal coaches do a better job of helping contestants with song choice (Summertime, again, really? For someone who wants to be on the radio?). Anyone who chooses a song or vocal style like broadway for their first song is at a disadvantage. I hope Julie Z gets another chance. She needs to lose the princess image and pick a better song. Pia killed it.

Posted by: bethechange1 | March 3, 2011 6:46 AM | Report abuse

Great article! Unfortunately all true!
These Judges are milking the audience for applause, and are there to promote their own agendas. LOVE the light box added under J-Lo's face, just in case she isn't glowing enough!
Also noted, was J-Lo's 'coaching' of Performers while they were performing.
Is that allowed? I call it a foul!

Posted by: LAinNY | March 3, 2011 7:45 AM | Report abuse

So far, I like the boys better this season. Thia and Lauren were the two girls I liked best. Pia was fine but not standing "O" fine. Julie and Karen were good. That was about it. Tonight should be interesting.

Posted by: MILWI | March 3, 2011 9:50 AM | Report abuse

I totally disagree, Lisa. I think the girls blew the guys of the water! I fast-forwarded through most of the guys' performances. I must say that Julie Z. makes me cringe. She really needs to wear something other than the poufy dresses. I fast-forwarded through her performance for that alone.

Posted by: cwarddc | March 3, 2011 9:56 AM | Report abuse

Wow. Rhe girls ranged from awful to less awful and the guys were much better two nights ago.

Posted by: ozpunk | March 3, 2011 10:01 AM | Report abuse

When all the women perform consecutively, it becomes even more glaring how they feel they have to use sex to sell their songs, which made Thia Megia's more-innocent song choice so refreshing. I also noticed that the only time the other female contestants didn't stand in ovation was for Julie Zorilla, who is a bit over-confident.

Posted by: SpurdyBradlock | March 3, 2011 2:40 PM | Report abuse

Post a Comment

We encourage users to analyze, comment on and even challenge's articles, blogs, reviews and multimedia features.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.

characters remaining

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company